📰 From the news · Other
"96.77% first-time pass rate": the Caribbean medical school the US Federal Trade Commission said told students the wrong numbers
Not every harmful school is a fake one. Saint James School of Medicine is a real, for-profit Caribbean medical school with campuses in Anguilla and St Vincent, and it enrolled real students — mostly from the United States and Canada. In April 2022 the US Federal Trade Commission announced action against the school, its Illinois-based operator Human Resource Development Services, Inc., and its operator Kaushik Guha, over how it marketed itself.
According to the FTC, the school's materials claimed a "96.77% FIRST TIME USMLE STEP 1 PASS RATE" and offered a "USMLE Step 1 pass guarantee". The FTC said the true figure since 2017 was about 35% of students who completed the coursework — far below US and Canadian schools. Telemarketers were instructed to quote residency match rates of 85–95%, and marketing showed students holding "I MATCHED" signs; the FTC put the actual average match rate since 2018 at 63%. The FTC also alleged that the school's financing contracts omitted legally required notices, effectively trying to waive students' federal rights.
The settlement required a $1.2 million judgment to be used for refunds and debt cancellation, notification to borrowers whose debt was cancelled, a ban on misrepresenting pass rates and residency outcomes, a prohibition on unsubstantiated claims, and compliance with consumer-credit rules. The school did not admit wrongdoing as part of the settlement.
Why this belongs on a scam-awareness site: a student deciding between schools relies on exactly two numbers — the licensing-exam pass rate and the residency or job placement rate. If those numbers are inflated, every other check (real campus, real accreditation, real degree) still leads to a bad outcome: years of tuition debt and a degree that does not turn into a career. This is true far beyond the Caribbean. Any school or agent quoting FMGE, PLAB, USMLE, MQE or licensing pass rates should be asked for the source and the denominator ("pass rate of whom, out of how many?").
Where to find real numbers: the exam bodies themselves publish results by school in many countries (India's NBEMS publishes FMGE results by institution; ECFMG and the NRMP publish US match data). If the only source of a statistic is the school's brochure or the agent's WhatsApp, treat it as advertising.
Were you affected by this case, or something like it? Report it with your own evidence, or tell your story — first-person accounts are what stop the next family.
This is a news-sourced case summary written by the TrustMBBS team, not a first-person account; see the sources above. They reflect one person's experience and are not a verdict on any institution. Report your own: Report a scam or tell your story.